Frustrations of a Mover and Shaker for Managerial Accounting

October 2, 2012 5:59 am 0 comments Views:

Share this Article

  • TwitterTwitter
  • Facebook
  • DeliciousDelicious
  • Digg
  • StumbleuponStumble
  • RedditReddit
  • Follow Me on PinterestPinterest
  • Google+

Tags:

Author:

 

Source:

 

Many who just read “managerial accounting” in this blog’s title are not bothering to read this. Why? They do not care. They only care about external financial reporting for regulatory agencies, bankers, and investors. This frustrates me because I interpret this as their not caring about managers and employees who need better internal managerial accounting information for insights and foresight to make better decisions compared to what they are currently provided by their CFO’s function.

Should I laugh or cry?

Allow me to share with you some examples of what frustrates me related to this topic.

In a recent discussion thread in the website of the Institute of Management Accountants (IMA)there was a post that described how to calculate product and standard service-line costs. The writer meticulously listed the steps. In the final instruction they wrote to “allocate” the indirect and shared support expenses one should use broadly-averaged basis like the number of direct labor input hours, headcount, or square feet. I did not know whether I should laugh or cry! Where have they been the last few decades?

This primitive cost allocation method totally violates the costing principle of a cause-and-effect relationship between changes in the amount of workload and the products and services that consume those expenses. Activity-based costing (ABC) resolves this. ABC has been researched and promoted since the 1980s. (I was trained in 1988 by ABC’s lead promoter, Harvard Business School’s Professor Robert S. Kaplan. I subsequently wrote several books on ABC.) After implementing my first ABC system, the company was shocked by how different the product costs and profit margins were compared to their existing “cost peanut butter spreading” method. They were exact in total, but not with the parts. I then thought the practice of ABC would take off like a rocket. It hasn’t, but its acceptance continues with a slow but increasing pace. Too slow for me.

But wait. There is more!

This blog may now appear to be like a television Ginza knives commercial. There is more!

I am involved with five university faculty to author a report for the American Accounting Association on reforms for university accounting course curriculums to shift the emphasis of teaching topics from financial to managerial accounting methods. It is a noble effort. What concerns me is how sensitive my co-writers are to the resistance from accounting faculty that this shift would be different from what accounting professors already teach. We will never move finance and accounting professionals from “bean counters to bean growers” if we continue with traditional practices.

Another example of my frustration involves adversarial competition for managerial accounting practices. Often driven by self-serving consultants, they advocate managerial accounting methods that only serve their interest. The late Theory of Constraints (TOC) guru Eli Goldratt proclaimed, “Cost accounting is enemy number one of productivity.” He proposed the throughput accounting method, which with investigation only applies under very special conditions of a 24 / 7 / 365 existence of a physical bottleneck like a heat treat oven in a foundry. Some lean accounting advocates slam ABC as being misguided. Both of these methods, if exclusively used, deny strategic analysts understanding of the profit margins of products, services, channels, and customers.

Cutting through the Clutter

I participated on a task force that recently published a report for the IMA titled “The Conceptual Framework for Managerial Accounting.” It is an exposure draft that anyone interested in it can review and comment on. Our task force’s mission was to determine key accounting principles to reflect economic reality that any managerial accounting system should comply with.

Many organization’s existing practices would fail compliance with the report’s framework. With financial accounting, if the CFO gets the numbers wrong, they can go to jail! But when they get the managerial accounting information, they don’t go to jail. Nor should they. But at least CFOs should feel embarrassed and irresponsible that they are performing a disservice to their organization’s workforce who increasingly needs much better management accounting information from which to further apply business analytics.

Am I a mover and shaker I note in this blog’s title to shift emphasis from financial accounting to managerial accounting? I try to be. And I am not alone. If I have inspired you, see my website atwww.garycokins.com where I am providing many free articles that “champions” in organizations can leverage to educate others. Better management accounting is needed for good decision making.

In the land of the blind, the one-eyed man is king.

By Gary Cokins, EPM Contributor, from: http://bigfatfinanceblog.com/2012/09/23/frustrations-of-a-mover-and-shaker-for-managerial-accounting/

Gary Cokins is an internationally recognized expert, speaker, and author in advanced cost management and performance improvement systems. He is the founder of Analytics-Based Performance Management LLC at www.garycokins.com in Cary, North Carolina. His career: First ten years as an executive with a division executive with FMC Corporation; next fifteen years in consulting with Deloitte, KPMG, and EDS; and last fifteen years as  a Principal Consultant with SAS, a leading provider of business intelligence and analytics software.

 

Leave a Reply



six − = 5

Latest News

  • EPM Finance Resources White Papers

    Setting Expections in SaaS - the Service Level Agreement

    The emergence of the Software as a Service (SaaS) model has necessitated new relationships between the service provider and the consumer with respect to service availability, service performance and response times. The Service Level Agreement (SLA) has evolved to become a useful tool which governs both service expectations and the consequences of failure to meet
    these agreed upon metrics.

    Read more →
  • accounting EPM Featured Finance Strategy Improving Strategy Execution through Effective Budgeting

    Improving Strategy Execution through Effective Budgeting

    Budgeting is nearly always portrayed as a management process that helps an organisation  to execute strategy.  Fine words indeed, but how many budgets and associated budget processes actually support that ideal?  Surveys reveal the reality that most budgets are totally disconnected from strategy and that the resources essential to success are often missing or unavailable.  In this short, practical article based on the best practices of high-performing companies, we show you how to design a budget process that will directly [...]

    Read more →
  • Biz Intelligence EPM Management Strategy How to Stop Hospitals From Killing Us

    How to Stop Hospitals From Killing Us

    Medical errors kill enough people to fill four jumbo jets a week. A surgeon with five simple ways to make health care safer.

    When there is a plane crash in the U.S., even a minor one, it makes headlines. There is a thorough federal investigation, and the tragedy often yields important lessons for the aviation industry. Pilots and airlines thus learn how to do their jobs more safely.

    The world of American medicine is far deadlier: Medical mistakes kill enough people each week to fill four jumbo jets. But these mistakes go largely unnoticed by the world at large, and the medical community rarely learns from them. The same preventable mistakes are made over and over again, and patients are left in the dark about which hospitals have significantly better (or worse) safety records than their peers.

    Read more →
  • EPM Featured Management Getting Big Projects Done: Balancing Task-Focus with Goal-Focus

    Getting Big Projects Done: Balancing Task-Focus with Goal-Focus

    Successfully completing large, complex projects can bring great commercial, scientific or artistic rewards. Unfortunately these types of projects, by their very nature, also provide endless opportunities to falter along the way.

    Early hiccups can send motivation into a tailspin, doubts cloud good judgement and the wood is lost for all the trees. There are so many reasons to jack it all in or do a bad job, and we need only choose one. That’s why any insight from psychology is welcome.

    How do you get team members to learn how to divide their attention between task- and goal-focus?

    Read more →
  • Featured Uncategorized Don’t Look Now, There’s a GPS Tracker in Your Kit-Kat Bar

    Don’t Look Now, There’s a GPS Tracker in Your Kit-Kat Bar

    Nestle Embeds GPS Trackers In Candy Bars To Hunt Down Eaters. Select Kit-Kat bars in the UK will contain GPS devices, which Nestlé will use to find the buyers and give them a cash prize.

    Customers buying Kit-Kat bars in the United Kingdom could be unwrapping a 21st-century version of Willy Wonka’s Golden Ticket-a GPS unit the candy-maker will use to find them, apprehend them and give them a prize. Nestlé claims to be the first to market its chocolatey wares with a GPS-based promotion.

    Crazy? Sinister?

    Read more →
  • EPM Featured Finance Management Risk Management Why Do Some CEOs Take More Risks?

    Why Do Some CEOs Take More Risks?

    Everyone has different attitudes to risk. Our individual judgments, interpretations and preferences influence the way we approach risky decisions. Sometimes, we can weigh the odds in a fairly rational, mathematical way. But when chief executive officers (CEOs) take big decisions such as acquiring another firm, it is very hard for them to know in advance how likely different outcomes are. Risk taking is not so much an economic calculus as an interpretive act.

    Read more →
  • accounting CapEx EPM Featured Finance FP&A Risk Management Why is Only 5% of Finance Delivering Value?

    Why is Only 5% of Finance Delivering Value?

    ?Only 5% of respondentssay their Finance organization is delivering Game Changing Value today? What’s that about?? Find out.

    Read more →
  • accounting EPM Featured Finance Frustrations of a Mover and Shaker for Managerial Accounting

    Frustrations of a Mover and Shaker for Managerial Accounting

    Many who just read “managerial accounting” in this blog’s title are not bothering to read this. Why? They do not care. They only care about external financial reporting for regulatory agencies, bankers, and investors. This frustrates me because I interpret this as their not caring about managers and employees who need better internal managerial accounting information for insights and foresight to make better decisions compared to what they are currently provided by their CFO’s function.

    Read more →